Stop here if you smell gas. Leave the house on foot, don't flip switches or use a phone inside, and call 911 and your gas utility from a safe distance (CenterPoint Energy's steps). The number is on your gas bill.
Headache, dizziness or nausea while the furnace runs? Those are on the CDC's list of carbon monoxide symptoms (CDC). If you suspect it, get everyone outside and call 911.
Five checks that cost nothing
- Thermostat. Set to Heat, with the temperature above the room's. Blank screen? Try fresh batteries.
- Power to the furnace. Check the breaker, and the wall switch near the furnace that looks like a light switch. Try once. If the breaker trips again, leave it off.
- Air filter. A clogged filter chokes the airflow. If it's gray and furry, replace it.
- Other gas appliances. If the stove and water heater work, gas is reaching the house. If none of them does, call your gas utility.
- Vents and registers. Make sure furniture, rugs or snow aren't blocking them.
Still cold? That's when to call. Tell them the checks you made.

Fix it, or start shopping?
HomeAdvisor's rule of thumb: if the repair quote is more than half the cost of a new furnace, and the furnace is 10 years old or more, replacing usually makes more sense (HomeAdvisor furnace repair). It also says a gas furnace typically lasts 15 to 25 years when it's looked after (HomeAdvisor furnace replacement).
Repair makes sense when
The furnace is newer, the part is a common one, and the quote is a few hundred dollars. The normal range is $133 to $505, and a flame sensor or ignitor sits at the low end (HomeAdvisor furnace repair, June 20, 2026).
Replacement is worth pricing when
The furnace is 15 or more years old, it keeps breaking, or the quote nears half of a new one. New furnaces run $2,823 to $6,897 installed, so half is roughly $1,400 to $3,400 (HomeAdvisor furnace replacement, June 17, 2026; the halving is our arithmetic).
A Dayton heating season, in numbers
The cold season runs December 2 to March 2, with an average January high of 37°F and low of 23°F, and snow typically falls from late November to late March (Weather Spark). The median Dayton home was built in 1951 and two in three were built before 1960 (Census ACS 2024), so ask the company how old your furnace is and what else in the system is original.
Once a year, before the cold
Both the Consumer Product Safety Commission and the CDC recommend a yearly professional check of fuel-burning heating equipment, including furnaces, chimneys and vents (CPSC, CDC). A tune-up is listed at $125 to $200 (HomeAdvisor furnace repair).
Who to call for what
- Whole street dark: the power company. AES Ohio has an outage page and map.
- Smell of gas: 911 and your gas utility. Gas in Dayton has come from CenterPoint Energy Ohio, and a sale to National Fuel Gas was reported complete on October 1, 2026 (Investing.com). Use the number on your latest bill.
- Furnace won't heat, no smell: a heating and cooling company. That's the call this site connects.
A furnace replacement is HVAC work, and the City of Dayton says new HVAC work, or changes to it, needs a permit (city page). Ohio HVAC contractors are licensed by the state, so ask for the license number (eLicense lookup).
See the full price tables.